AFL-CIO
Congressional Voting Record (COPE)

Gordon Smith

View the voting record of Gordon Smith on bills that represent a wide range of the issues most important to working people and their families.

2001 U.S. Senate

Right Votes—44%
Right—7	Wrong—9
Lifetime Right—17%

ASHCROFT ATTORNEY GENERAL NOMINATION
President Bush nominated John Ashcroft to be U.S. attorney general. However, Ashcroft’s record as a U.S. senator and Missouri attorney general raised serious questions about his suitability to be the nation’s top law enforcement officer. Ashcroft’s controversial stands on civil rights, his opposition to a school desegregation plan in his home state and his Senate votes against women’s and workers’ rights lead the AFL-CIO, civil rights and women’s groups to oppose the nomination. Ashcroft was confirmed Feb. 2, 2001, by a 58–42 vote. Y=W; N=R (REP: 50–0; DEM: 8–42) Smith's Vote: Yes	Wrong Vote
ERGONOMICS
ERGONOMICS—S.J. Res. 6—In November 2000, after more than a decade of struggle by workers and their unions demanding federal rules to prevent crippling repetitive stress injuries in the workplace, the Occupation Safety and Health Administration issued the nation’s first workplace ergonomics standard. But business and congressional allies, with the support of the newly installed Bush administration, renewed their decade-long fight against the standard. Using the Congressional Review Act (CRA) for the first time ever, the Senate overturned the ergonomics standard. It was the first time in OSHA’s 30-year history that Congress nullified one of its safety standards. The CRA “resolution of disapproval” vote not only eliminated the ergonomic standard, it also prohibited OSHA from issuing another similar rule unless Congress gives the agency specific permission to act. The measure passed on March 6, 2001, 56–44. Y=W; N=R (REP: 50–0; DEM: 6–44) Smith's Vote: Yes	Wrong Vote
CAMPAIGN FINANCE REFORM/PAYCHECK DECEPTION
S. 27—During Senate consideration of campaign finance reform, Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah) sought to silence working families and their unions in the political arena by offering a “paycheck deception” amendment to the bill. The amendment would have prohibited unions from collecting membership dues or fees from any union-represented employee who had not filled out a form authorizing the union’s political activities. Proponents of this amendment argued that it also would have forbidden corporations from spending their general treasury funds for political activities if they failed to get written authorization from their individual shareholders. But,in fact,it would have exempted 99.7 percent of all corporations because they are privately owned and have no shareholders to notify. Moreover, it would have allowed publicly held corporations to continue making the same amount of political expenditures simply by changing their internal accounting practices. Finally, this amendment also would have imposed burdensome reporting requirements on unions, but only very limited reporting requirements on corporations. A motion to table, which had the same effect as defeating the amendment, passed on March 21, 2001, by a 69–31 vote. Y=R; N=W (REP: 19–31; DEM: 50–0) Smith's Vote: No	Wrong Vote
PRESCRIPTION DRUGS
H. Con. Res. 83—In an effort to provide a strong Medicare prescription drug benefit to seniors, Sen. Max Baucus (D-Mont.) offered an amendment to the fiscal year 2002 budget resolution conference report that included $311 billion over 10 years for a Medicare prescription drug benefit. The budget resolution, backed by Republicans and the Bush administration, offered inadequate funding for a Medicare prescription drug benefit. The amendment would have taken $158 billion that the resolution set aside for a tax cut mainly for the wealthy and increased the inadequate funds in the budget resolution for a Medicare prescription drug benefit program by the same amount. The measure failed April 3, 2001, by a 50–50 vote. Y=R; N=W (REP: 1–49: DEM: 49–1) Smith's Vote: No	Wrong Vote
BUDGET
H. Con. Res. 83— The fiscal year 2002 budget resolution called for spending $1.65 trillion of projected budget surpluses in fiscal years 2001–2011 to pay for tax cuts that primarily would benefit the wealthy. It weakened Social Security and Medicare, earmarked $600 billion of Social Security Trust Fund surpluses for such Social Security “reforms” as privatization and failed to make investments in such important working family areas as repairing and rebuilding the nation’s public schools and improving workplace health and safety. In all, the budget resolution contained spending cuts for important domestic programs of $5.5 billion in FY 2002 and $61.5 billion over the next 10 years. The resolution passed May 10, 2001, by a 53–47 vote. Y=W; N=R (REP: 48–2; DEM: 5–45) Smith's Vote: Yes	Wrong Vote
SCHOOL CONSTRUCTION
S. 1—Many of America’s schools are in serious need of repair and modernization. Students who attend class in dilapidated, hazardous and sometimes dangerous buildings have a difficult time learning. Many schools are not equipped to provide the high-tech education today’s students must have. During consideration of the Elementary and Secondary School Act, Sen. Tom Harkin (D-Iowa) offered an amendment to authorize $1.6 billion in fiscal year 2002 to help states and local school districts repair their most dilapidated public school buildings. The measure was defeated May 16, 2001, 49–50. Y=R; N=W (REP: 1–49; DEM: 48–1) Smith's Vote: No	Wrong Vote
TAX RECONCILIATION/MILLIONAIRE TAX
Conference Report on H.R. 1836—President Bush’s millionaire tax cut received its final Senate approval with the passage of the conference report on the fiscal year 2002 tax reconciliation bill. The legislation uses $1.74 trillion of the projected budget surpluses over the next 10 years to pay for tax cuts that would primarily benefit the wealthy ($1.35 trillion for the tax cuts themselves and $390 billion for additional interest payments on the federal debt that these tax cuts would require). According to Citizens for Tax Justice, more than 38 percent of the tax cut benefits will go to the wealthiest 1 percent of taxpayers, who make $373,000 or more annually. Spending most of the projected budget surpluses to pay for tax cuts makes it virtually impossible for future sessions of Congress to strengthen Social Security and Medicare, add a prescription drug benefit to Medicare and make needed investments in education and health care. This legislation, however, did improve Section 415 of the tax code to fix retirement rules capping multiemployer plan benefits. The conference report was approved May 26, 2001, in a 58–33 vote. Y=W; N=R (REP: 46–2; DEM: 12–31) Smith's Vote: Yes	Wrong Vote
SCHOOL VOUCHERS
S. 1—Private school vouchers use taxpayers’ money—which could be used to improve public schools—to pay for private and religious school tuition. Private schools, unlike public schools, which are open to all students, can exclude students for several reasons. During the debate on the Elementary and Secondary School Act, S. 1, Sen. Judd Gregg (R-N.H.) offered an amendment that would have created a demonstration program to allow three states and 10 school districts to use federal funds to pay for private school expenses. The measure was defeated June 12, 2001, 41–58. Y=W; N=R (REP: 38–11; DEM: 3–46; I: 0–1) Smith's Vote: No	Right Vote
PATIENTS’ BILL OF RIGHTS
S. 1052—Quality, affordable and accessible health care should be available to all working families. The Patients’Bill of Rights the Senate considered guarantees access to specialty and emergency room care and allows patients to appeal coverage and treatment decisions by their health plan to an independent panel. It also allows patients to sue their health insurer if they suffer harm. The bill would not allow lawsuits against multiemployer (Taft-Hartley) health plans over nonmedical decisions. The bill passed on June 29, 2001, 59–36. Y=R; N=W (REP 9–35; DEM: 50–0; I: 0–1) Smith's Vote: Yes	Right Vote
NAFTA—TRUCK SAFETY
H.R. 2299—President Bush, citing provisions of the North American Free Trade Agreement, proposed to open U.S. roads and highways to Mexican trucks beyond the limited border zone in which they have been allowed to operate. However, those trucks are not held to the same safety standards as U.S. trucks under federal standards. Border inspections revealed that almost half of these Mexican trucks had serious safety violations. An amendment to the Department of Transportation spending bill that would prohibit trucks and buses from Mexico from operating in the United States beyond the current zone was passed July 26, 2001, in a 70–30 vote. Y=R; N=W (REP: 19–30; DEM: 50–0; I: 1–0) Smith's Vote: Yes	Right Vote
PRISON LABOR
S. 1438—The Federal Prison Industry Program was established in 1934 to provide a small range of products the private sector was not producing for federal government agencies and to help inmates gain some job skills. But today, with 21,000 inmates in 100 factories and sales of products and services of $566.2 million annually, FPI ranks 36th among the top 100 government contractors. Private-sector companies are not allowed to compete with FPI; in fact, under current law, federal agencies actually must obtain FPI’s permission to even solicit competing offers from private firms. S. 1438 would allow private firms to compete for Defense Department contracts currently limited to FPI. It also would provide additional vocational and educational opportunities for inmates. A motion to kill the amendment to eliminate the private-sector competition provisions of the bill passed Sept. 25, 2001, in a 74–24 vote. Y=R; N=W (REP: 30–19; DEM: 44–4; I: 0–1) Smith's Vote: Yes	Right Vote
AVIATION WORKER RELIEF
S. 1447—Tens of thousands of aviation industry workers were laid off because of the economic impact of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks on the United States. The aviation security bill introduced in the Senate contained $15 billion in loans and loan guarantees for the airlines but failed to provide any assistance to those workers. Sen. Jean Carnahan (D-Mo.) offered an amendment that would have provided unemployment, job-training and health benefits to displaced workers. However, Republican leaders and most Republican senators opposed the amendment and mounted a filibuster against it. A motion to end the filibuster and vote on the Carnahan amendment failed on Oct. 11, 2001, 56–44. Y=R; N=W (REP: 5–44; DEM: 50–0; I: 1–0) Smith's Vote: No	Wrong Vote
WORKERS’ RIGHTS
H.R. 3061—Under the National Labor Relations Act, if employers allow organizations, including charities, to distribute materials to or solicit contributions from employees and customers on their sites, they must provide the same access to labor unions. During debate on the fiscal year 2002 Labor, Health and Human Services and Education spending bill, anti-union senators offered an amendment that would have allowed employers to unfairly restrict the free speech rights of labor unions by allowing charitable organizations, but not unions, to access worksites. Although proponents of this amendment argued that employers needed it to be able to allow charities to solicit funds for the victims of the Sept. 11 attacks, employers can do this now under current law. Thus, the proponents of this amendment were simply trying to use the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks to discriminate against labor unions. The amendment was rejected Nov. 1, 2001, 40–59. Y=W; N=R (REP: 39–9; DEM: 1–49; I: 0–1) Smith's Vote: No	Right Vote
COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
H.R. 3061—While the nation recognized the Sept. 11 heroism of public safety officers—firefighters, police officers and emergency medical professionals—some senators refused to fully recognize the officers’ rights. An amendment to the fiscal year 2002 Labor, Health and Human Services and Education spending bill to providecollective bargaining rights for firefighters, police and other public safety officers employed by state and local municipalities was met with a filibuster. Public safety officers in 32 states already have collective bargaining rights, which the bill would have extended to the remaining 18 states. The motion to end the filibuster and vote on the amendment failed on Nov. 6, 2001, 56–44. Sixty votes are needed to end a filibuster. Y=R; N=W (REP: 7–42; DEM: 48–2; I: 1–0) Smith's Vote: Yes	Right Vote
ECONOMIC STIMULUS
H.R. 3090—The economic aftershocks of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks on the United States, combined with the Bush recession, resulted in the lay-offs of hundreds of thousands of workers. The AFL-CIO and other working family advocates backed an economic stimulus plan to extend, expand and improve unemployment insurance benefits to help families make up for lost income; to help laid-off workers maintain or acquire health insurance; to provide funds to enable state unemployment systems to meet the surge in claims; and to provide help to the business community. However, the Bush administration and Republican leaders insisted on a stimulus package made up mostly of huge tax breaks for corporations and the wealthy and few benefits for jobless workers. Sen. Max Baucus (D-Mont.) offered legislation to provide approximately $73 billion for economic stimulus measures in fiscal year 2002, including $14 billion for refund checks to taxpayers who did not receive refunds during the summer of 2001. It also would provide $31 billion for unemployment and health care benefits for displaced workers. It called for $15 billion over 10 years for homeland security, including measures to combat bioterrorism, enhance law enforcement and protect postal operations. Before the bill could come to a vote, Senate budget rules would have had to be waived, which requires 60 votes. The motion to waive the rules failed on Nov. 14, 2001, 51–47. Y=R; N=W (REP: 0–47; DEM: 50–0; I: 1–0) Smith's Vote: No	Wrong Vote
RAILWAY RETIREMENT
H.R. 10—Rail workers and their unions backed legislation to boost the value of their pension fund assets. The legislation would increase benefits for retired railroad workers and their spouses and survivors. It alsowould create a railroad retirement board with authority to invest the pension system’s $15.3 billion in Treasury bonds in higher-yielding private equities. The bill passed on Dec. 12, 2001, 90–9. Y=R; N=W (REP: 40–9; DEM: 49–0; I: 1–0) Smith's Vote: Yes	Right Vote

Voting record compiled and provided by the AFL-CIO.

[Voting Record Home]

www.oraflcio.org